By Wendy Xiao Herman, MD, PhD (Pediatric Neurologist Expert Witness)
When evaluating an HIE birth injury claim, attorneys often see hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy (HIE) in a newborn’s chart and treat the diagnosis as definitive proof of delivery trauma. As a pediatric neurologist and medical expert who reviews cases involving newborn brain injury, I first separate the diagnosis written in the medical record from what the entire clinical record shows happened.
By definition, HIE indicates abnormal brain function caused by too little oxygen or blood flow to the brain. Doctors often write this diagnosis in the first hours after birth, before all the facts are in. They have six hours to start a cooling treatment that protects the newborn’s brain, so they act fast and sort out the cause later. A diagnosis made under this time pressure does not, by itself, prove the delivery caused permanent brain injury.
Consider a common scenario. A full-term baby is born after a difficult labor. The fetal heart monitor showed concerning patterns. The baby has low Apgar scores (a 0 to 10 rating of a newborn’s condition at birth) and needs help breathing. In the neonatal intensive care unit (NICU), the baby is floppy and hard to wake, and the team starts cooling. The chart now lists HIE. Years later, the child has developmental delays. Does the HIE diagnosis prove the delivery caused permanent brain injury? I work through five questions to answer this.
1. Was There an Event Capable of Causing Hypoxic-Ischemic Injury?
I start by looking for a sudden event during labor or delivery that cut off oxygen or blood flow to the baby. Doctors call this a sentinel event. Examples include the placenta separating from the uterus (placental abruption), a tear in the uterus (uterine rupture), the umbilical cord slipping out ahead of the baby (umbilical cord prolapse), a sustained drop in the baby’s heart rate (severe fetal bradycardia), a shoulder getting stuck during delivery (shoulder dystocia), or a mother collapsing from a condition such as a blood clot in the lungs (pulmonary embolism) or a severe infection (septic shock).
The fetal heart monitor alone rarely answers this question. Many tracings look worrisome without any harm to the baby. A tracing that stays clearly abnormal for a long time carries more weight, especially alongside other evidence. One strong clue is damage to other organs. Oxygen loss severe enough to injure the brain usually injures the heart, kidneys, or lungs too, and the lab results and NICU notes from the first days of life show this.
2. Why Was Therapeutic Hypothermia Started?
Brief respiratory support or low Apgar scores alone are common after delivery and do not establish lasting neurologic injury. Most of these babies develop normally. To qualify for cooling, a baby generally needs low Apgar scores at 10 minutes of life, or still needs breathing support at 10 minutes. A baby who only requires extra oxygen does not qualify.
The cord blood gas is the other test to check. Taken from the umbilical cord at delivery, this test measures how much acid built up in the baby’s blood. A lower pH means more acid. Acid rises when a baby goes without oxygen. Cooling protocols look for severe acid buildup, such as a pH of 7.0 or lower.
Because the treatment window is short, clinicians sometimes appropriately begin cooling before the cause of the newborn’s abnormal neurologic examination is fully understood.
When I later review the case as a pediatric neurologist, I have the benefit of the infant’s full medical course, including the electroencephalogram (EEG), brain magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), neurologic findings, and later development.
Cooling shows that the infant met enough clinical concern, and often enough protocol criteria, to justify treatment. It does not retrospectively prove that a hypoxic-ischemic event occurred or that permanent brain injury resulted.
Cooling shows that the infant met enough clinical concern, and often enough protocol criteria, to justify treatment. It does not retrospectively prove that a hypoxic-ischemic event occurred or that permanent brain injury resulted.
-Wendy Xiao Herman, MD, PhD
3. Neonatal Encephalopathy Does Not Always Mean HIE
This is one of the most important distinctions I make when reviewing these cases.
Neonatal encephalopathy means a newborn’s brain is not working normally. The baby is hard to wake, floppy, slow to react, has seizures, or breathes poorly. Low oxygen (HIE) is one cause. Many other conditions produce the same signs, including medications given to the mother, infection, bleeding in the brain, stroke, genetic conditions, and problems with how the brain formed (congenital brain abnormalities).
Two examples show how this plays out. Magnesium, a medication given to mothers with pre-eclampsia (dangerously high blood pressure in pregnancy), makes newborns temporarily floppy and slow to breathe. This looks like brain injury and leads to cooling. In another case, a shoulder gets stuck during delivery and the nerves to the baby’s arm are stretched. The arm moves poorly, the exam looks abnormal, and the team starts cooling.
Starting cooling in these cases is reasonable. Doctors must begin within six hours, so they treat first and search for the cause afterward. Brain wave monitoring (EEG) checks for seizures, but seizures do not point to one cause. HIE in the chart often records the reason cooling started, not a final conclusion.
4. What Does the Objective Evidence Show?
Cooling generally lasts 72 hours, with EEG monitoring for seizures. After they rewarm the infant, the team usually orders a brain MRI. Timing matters. An MRI done too early misses injury still developing, and some neurologists order a second scan about a week later to see how the injury changed.
Certain patterns of brain injury are more consistent with hypoxic-ischemic injury in the appropriate clinical setting. For example, an MRI may show injury involving the basal ganglia and thalami, deep structures in the brain involved in movement and other functions. Another pattern may involve watershed regions, areas of the brain located between the territories supplied by major blood vessels and therefore susceptible to reduced blood flow.
A normal MRI does not rule out all injury, but any oxygen-related injury in this setting is likely mild, and mild injury alone usually has a small effect on development.
Two more points help attorneys read these records. Small brain bleeds during delivery are common in full-term babies and usually do not mean the baby was injured. Cooling also does not prove permanent brain damage. Doctors cool babies when injury might be developing, and they often cool babies with mild symptoms to be safe, even though research shows little benefit in mild cases.
The case for an HIE birth injury gets much stronger when the records line up: a sentinel event, severe acid buildup, damage to other organs, a clearly abnormal brain exam within hours of birth, and an MRI pattern typical of hypoxic-ischemic injury.
5. Are There Other Explanations for the Child’s Outcome?
Causation analysis should not stop when the infant leaves the NICU.
If the records show no clear event and no typical MRI pattern, look beyond the newborn period. Developmental delay, cerebral palsy, epilepsy, and learning problems often have more than one cause. These conditions often affect development far more than mild oxygen-related injury:
- Genetic or metabolic disorders
- Congenital brain abnormalities
- Infection or inflammatory conditions
- Prematurity and its associated complications
- Illness or injury after the newborn period
- Toxin exposure, such as lead in water or the home
- Environmental and social factors that may affect developmental assessment, access to services, or the timing of intervention
An HIE diagnosis in the chart matters. So does the decision to initiate therapeutic hypothermia. Neither answers the causation question by itself.
-Wendy Xiao Herman, MD, PhD
Questions to Consider When Reviewing an HIE Birth injury Case
- Did a sudden event during labor or delivery cut off the baby’s oxygen?
- Do the fetal heart tracing, cord blood gas, Apgar scores, and resuscitation records tell the same story?
- Did the infant have moderate to severe brain dysfunction (encephalopathy) or seizures?
- Did the infant meet the criteria for cooling, and did the team follow the protocol?
- When was the MRI performed, and what pattern did it show?
- Does objective evidence link a delivery event to the child’s later problems?
- Could another condition explain the newborn’s symptoms or the child’s later delays?
An HIE diagnosis in the chart matters. So does the decision to initiate therapeutic hypothermia. Neither answers the causation question by itself.
My role as a pediatric neurology expert is to reconstruct the clinical course, determine whether the evidence supports a true hypoxic-ischemic event, and assess whether that event medically explains the child’s later neurologic condition.
Attorneys:
Need an HIE birth injury expert? Contact Dr. Herman directly, or search the High Rock Experts Directory to find the right expert for your case.
About the Author

Wendy Xiao Herman, MD, PhD, is a pediatric neurologist at Massachusetts General Hospital who received sub-specialty training in fetal and neonatal neurology at Boston Children’s Hospital. She can be contacted at [email protected].
Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of High Rock Experts®. This content is for educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute medical or legal advice.
About High Rock Experts®
Trusted Medical Experts for Attorneys. Training Clinicians Attorneys Actually Hire.
Founded by Amy G. Fogelman, MD, High Rock Experts® has matched more than 800 medical experts with attorneys nationwide since 2018. Through High Rock® Academy, Dr. Fogelman trains clinicians to become medical experts attorneys actually hire.