Pediatric UTI Malpractice: 5 Questions About Delayed Diagnosis

Pediatric UTI malpractice cases featured in a High Rock Experts blog by Allison Schuessler, DO, MBA, discussing delayed diagnosis and pediatric standards of care.

By Allison Schuessler, DO, MBA · Pediatrician Expert Witness

Clinical Scenario · Composite Case Illustration

A 20-month-old girl was evaluated in the pediatrician’s office for two days of fever, decreased appetite, and vomiting. She did not have a cough, runny nose, rash, or another obvious source of infection. She was alert during the examination and able to drink. The clinician diagnosed a probable viral illness and discharged her with instructions to return if she worsened. No urine sample was obtained.

Two days later, she returned with persistent fever, lethargy, and dehydration. A urine sample collected through a catheter showed inflammation, and a urine culture grew Escherichia coli, an intestinal bacterium that is the most common cause of urinary tract infections in children. The same organism was later found in her blood, indicating that the infection had spread beyond the urinary tract.

Pediatric UTI malpractice cases often raise a difficult question: When should a clinician recognize a urinary tract infection in a young child with fever but no obvious source of infection?

Once the culture is positive and a child is seriously ill, it is tempting to conclude that the diagnosis should have been obvious at the first visit. The medical analysis is more complicated. Young children frequently develop fevers, most of which are caused by self-limited viral infections. The central questions are what information was available during each encounter, whether that information reasonably supported urine testing, and whether the clinician created an appropriate follow-up plan.

Young Children May Not Have Urinary Symptoms

A urinary tract infection is a bacterial infection involving the bladder, kidneys, or another part of the urinary system. Older children may report symptoms similar to adults including painful urination, frequent urination, urgency, abdominal pain, or back pain. However, infants and toddlers often cannot describe these symptoms or may not have them at all.

In a young child, the only sign of a urinary tract infection may be fever. Other nonspecific findings can include vomiting, irritability, poor feeding, decreased activity, or inadequate weight gain. These symptoms are nonspecific and are present in many other common childhood illnesses.

That does not mean every febrile child requires urine testing. Pediatricians consider the entire presentation, including:

  • The child’s age and sex
  • The height and duration of the fever
  • Circumcision status in a male child
  • Previous urinary tract infections
  • Known abnormalities of the kidneys or urinary system
  • The child’s appearance and hydration
  • Whether another convincing explanation for the fever is present
  • Whether symptoms are improving, persisting, or worsening

The presence of an apparent respiratory infection can lower suspicion for a urinary tract infection, but it does not always eliminate it. Conversely, the absence of a clear fever source does not prove that the urinary system is infected. Because young children are unable to produce clean-catch samples, catheters are often used to accurately diagnose urinary infections. The clinician must decide whether the probability is high enough to justify collecting urine, which can be uncomfortable and invasive in a young child.

Documentation becomes especially important when testing is deferred. A note that says only “viral illness” may not reveal whether the clinician considered a urinary tract infection, identified a convincing alternative diagnosis, or instructed the family to return if the fever persisted.

The Collection Method Determines What a Culture Means

A urinalysis is a rapid examination of urine for findings such as white blood cells or bacterial byproducts that suggest inflammation or infection. A urine culture is a laboratory test in which the urine is observed for bacterial growth over time. These tests provide related but different information.

The method used to collect the urine matters greatly.

A catheterized specimen is obtained by passing a small sterile tube through the urethra into the bladder. It reduces contamination from bacteria on the skin but is invasive. A clean-catch specimen is collected while the child urinates after the genital area has been cleaned. This can provide useful results but may be difficult to obtain reliably from a toddler. A bagged specimen is collected in an adhesive bag placed over the genital area. Although it may be useful for initial urinalysis, bacterial growth from a bagged specimen is difficult to interpret because contamination from bacteria on the skin is common.

A positive culture is therefore not automatically proof of a true infection. The reviewer should consider:

  • How the specimen was obtained
  • Whether the urinalysis showed inflammation
  • Which organism grew
  • Whether one organism or several organisms were present
  • The amount of bacterial growth
  • Whether antibiotics were given before collection
  • Whether the result fits the child’s symptoms and clinical course

A positive culture is not automatically proof of a true infection.

— Dr. Allison Schuessler, DO, MBA

Bacterial growth is often reported in colony-forming units per milliliter, an estimate of the number of viable bacteria in the urine. The significance of that number depends on the collection method and surrounding clinical evidence.

Under the American Academy of Pediatrics’ guideline, growth of a single urinary pathogen at 10,000 colony-forming units per milliliter from a catheterized specimen may support the diagnosis when the symptoms and urinalysis are also consistent with infection. A clean-catch specimen ordinarily requires a higher bacterial count.

The guideline is influential clinical guidance, but it is not a substitute for patient-specific medical analysis. It also should not be applied retroactively to care provided before its publication.

A Case May Turn on Follow-Up Rather Than the First Visit

Urine cultures generally require time to produce a final result. A child may therefore leave the office or emergency department before the clinician knows whether bacteria will grow or which antibiotic will be effective.

This creates a second point of potential failure: management of the pending result.

The record should identify who was responsible for reviewing the culture, how abnormal results were communicated, and what happened if the family could not be reached. If antibiotics had already been prescribed, the clinician should determine whether the organism was susceptible, meaning that it was likely to respond to the selected medication. A resistant organism may require a prompt change in treatment.

Families also need understandable return instructions. “Follow up as needed” communicates little. More useful instructions identify concerning developments such as persistent fever, worsening appearance, repeated vomiting, inability to drink, decreased urination, medication intolerance, or failure to improve within the expected period.

Imaging may also become relevant. The 2026 American Academy of Pediatrics guideline recommends a renal and bladder ultrasound, an imaging study that uses sound waves to examine the kidneys and bladder, after a first febrile urinary tract infection in a child younger than 5. Whether imaging was indicated, ordered, completed, and reviewed may matter when the child later develops another infection or is found to have an anatomic abnormality.

Causation in Pediatric UTI Malpractice Cases

In pediatric UTI malpractice cases, a missed or delayed diagnosis does not by itself establish that the delay caused the child’s eventual injury. The medical timeline must be analyzed separately.

Important causation questions include when the infection probably reached the kidneys or bloodstream, whether the child was already seriously ill during the first encounter, and whether earlier treatment probably would have changed the outcome. Pyelonephritis, which is an infection of the kidney, can develop before a child appears severely ill. Conversely, some children worsen rapidly despite appropriate evaluation and treatment.

A missed or delayed diagnosis does not by itself establish that the delay caused the child’s eventual injury.

— Dr. Allison Schuessler, DO, MBA

Later kidney abnormalities do not automatically prove that a diagnostic delay caused permanent injury. Reviewers should consider prior kidney or urinary abnormalities, recurrent infections, imaging findings, the duration of illness, response to treatment, and other possible causes.

Returning to the opening case, the positive urine and blood cultures at the second visit confirm that the child ultimately had a serious urinary tract infection that had spread to the bloodstream. Those later results do not, by themselves, establish whether urine testing was indicated at the first encounter or whether earlier treatment would have changed the outcome.

A meaningful review must reconstruct what was known at each visit, how the child’s condition evolved, how reliable the testing was, what happened after results became available, and whether the timing of care medically explains the child’s outcome.

5 Questions for Reviewing Pediatric UTI Malpractice Cases

When screening delayed UTI diagnosis claims, these five clinical questions guide standard of care and proximate causation evaluations:

  1. At each encounter, did the child have a convincing source for the fever, and was the clinical reasoning documented?
  2. Was urine testing considered, and if urine was collected, what collection method was used?
  3. Did the urinalysis, culture, symptoms, and clinical course support a true infection rather than contamination?
  4. Who reviewed the pending culture, contacted the family, and changed treatment if the organism was resistant to the initial antibiotic?
  5. Would earlier diagnosis and treatment probably have changed the outcome, based on the timing and mechanism of the claimed injury?

Evaluating a Pediatric Malpractice Claim?

Assessing standard of care and proximate causation in pediatric infectious disease cases requires active clinical expertise and objective analysis. Contact Dr. Schuessler directly for case evaluations, or explore our curated directory of board-certified medical experts.

About the Author

Allison Schuessler DO MBA Pediatrician Expert Witness

Allison Schuessler, DO, MBA, is a board-certified pediatrician with clinical experience in general pediatrics and pediatric emergency medicine. She practices at Geisinger Medical Center and St. Mary’s Medical Center and serves as an Associate Professor of Pediatrics at Geisinger Commonwealth School of Medicine in Pennsylvania. An award-winning clinical educator, she provides objective medical analysis in pediatric standards of care, clinical decision-making, and patient safety as an expert witness.

Contact: [email protected] · (484) 695-1304


Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of High Rock Experts®. This content is for educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute medical or legal advice.


About High Rock Experts®
Trusted Medical Experts for Attorneys. Training Clinicians Attorneys Actually Hire.
Founded by Amy G. Fogelman, MD, High Rock Experts® has matched more than 800 medical experts with attorneys nationwide since 2018.

Reference:
Alverson BK, Hains DS, Downs SM, et al. Clinical Practice Guideline for the Diagnosis and Treatment of Urinary Tract Infection in Children From 8 Days to 5 Years of Age. Pediatrics. 2026;158(4):e2026078565. doi:10.1542/peds.2026-078565

Disclaimer: Content is for educational and informational purposes only.

Posted In: , , , ,